In 2013, she signed with the competitive eating organization All Pro Eating. In August 2012, she became the first woman to complete the Stellanator, a food challenge at Stella’s Blue pancake and Grill in Bellevue, Nebraska. In October 2012, she won the Pig Wings Challenge at Starsky’s in Omaha, Nebraska, which had previously been featured on the Travel Channel’s Man v.
She later finished the Pig Wing challenge in under 12 minutes. She finished in 24 minutes, 56 seconds. Since she was the first person to win the challenge, she got to name the pizza, and named it “Molly’s Humble Pie. She did so again a few weeks later, and in January 2013 she did so a third time. 2 minutes and 44 seconds at Sayler’s Old Country Kitchen in Portland, Oregon.